Read. Write. Speak. Listen. Think.
  • Home
  • Honors English 9
    • Discussion
  • English 11
  • Questions?

Lord of the Flies discussion, week three

2/3/2014

 
Picture
Critics of the Lord of the Flies argue that the novel in general is somewhat dated and unsuitable for modern audiences.  Literary and movie critic Roger Ebert remarked in his review that "…events take place every day on our mean streets that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Golding's island."  Do you agree or disagree with the quote?  In your response, use evidence from the text, contrasted with real life examples.


Yulissa S. link
2/3/2014 08:22:24 am

"…events take place every day on our mean streets that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Golding's island."
This statement, in my opinion, is true. Though what the boys experienced on the island was brutal, murder is an everyday thing in the world. Either it be from war or just insanity, someone, somewhere in the world dies from the hands of another. The boys attacked one an other, but suffering did not seem to be prolonged. "Piggy feel forty feet and landed on his back across the square red rock in the sea. His head opened and stuff came out and turned red. Piggy's arms and legs twitched a bit..." (181) Piggy's death was sudden and quick. In our streets, adults, even children, are taken away from safety and put through hell and back. Days, or even years, people today have been tortured, and forced to suffer, something more gruesome than seen on the island. Things such as the holocaust, pain was dragged on. Some may say what happened on the island was worse, for it was kids killing kids, but we see this once again, almost everyday. School shootings happen more often than they ever should have. Books, such as Lord of the Flies, can portray death to be violent and unreal, but when in reality, stuff like this happens everyday all around us.

Kiarra R
2/3/2014 09:10:42 am

"... events take place everyday on our mean streets that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Golding's island." This statement in my opinion isn't accurate because the boys are supposed to represent the issues that are going on in the time period. Whether it be war or insanity the world always experiences what goes on in this story. Yes the boys are maybe not as brutal as the real world but as seen in Lord of the Flies they are capable or brutality. "At once the crowd surged after it, poured down the rock, leapt on the beast, screamed, struck, bit, tore." (153). I also disagree because not only did the boys start going crazy over power but they lost their innocence way to early for 6 to 12 year old children. I understand tat their are school shootings and suicide today could be seen as worse than what happens in Lord of the Flies but honestly aren't those things all happening in Golding's masterpiece plus add war to the equation it puts a lot of symbolism into the story that shows real world events that are going on in today's society even to this day.

Yulissa S. link
2/9/2014 07:10:13 am

I disagree with, "they lost their innocence way to early for 6 to 12 year old children". For the need to survive, they couldn't continue you to be innocent young children frolicking through a field of sunflowers while their life is on the line. In the story, no one committed suicide, nor did I mention anything about suicide, so you have me lost.

Carolina Orozco
2/8/2014 07:30:21 am

I agree with you. Although the book had many misfortunes, it has become something normal for us, something we must face every day. I also agree how Lord of the Flies portrays death like that, and really its something very common in our every day world. Yes the book was brutal, but so is life.

Susana Bedoya
2/9/2014 07:06:23 am

I agree with you, murder is an everyday thing in the world. It is sad and should not happen this often, but the book "The Lord of the Flies" can be a metaphor of these horrifying events going on in our world.

Sofia Duran
2/3/2014 09:33:55 am

I disagree with this quote because those "little monsters" are children that once were innocent. I also believe that these children won't act like this if this was really happening in real life...they sent suppose to act psycho like this they're just kids! Also, innocent was lost in this novel, children ages from 6-12 aren't able to kill one another...especially not in a book. I also disagree because this doesn't happen on our mean streets on an everyday basis. Well on this book yea...they killed Simon, thinking he was the beast; and piggy is still accusing it to be Simon's fault for calling at night! I don't know...it's crazy and weird and sad at the same time...but I still disagree with the quote!!!!

Gavin M.
2/4/2014 06:55:02 am

I agree with the fact that these children are just young and innocent kids, but they have grown to know a new type of right. Almost everything they do is for (or so they think) survival. If you were stuck in a forest with nothing but a few people that you didn't even know, would you sacrifice someone if you thought that it meant any kind of survival whatsoever? I know I would.

Andrea Hernandez
2/5/2014 10:36:32 pm

I agree with Gavin that if I was stuck on an island with strangers, I would do anything possible to survive. But, I believe that is someone is pushed to the limit, they will do whatever it takes to survive, be it the youngest or oldest age. so I disagree with your statement Sofia that children wont act like this if it were happening in real life. Just like Ralph was pushed into killing a sow, and all the other boys were pushed into killing Simon, anyone is capable of doing whatever needed when the occasion arises.

Gavin M.
2/4/2014 06:51:19 am

I do agree with this quote, "…events take place every day on our mean streets that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Golding's island." I agree because sometimes even though these kids torture each other very brutally and unnecessarily, they still don't know any better. However, when day-to-day basis crimes and felonies happen, these people do it out of sheer and utter madness. They might be doing it for a worthy and thoughtful cause, but on the inside, these people know what is wrong and what isn't.

Michael S.
2/6/2014 10:42:30 am

I agree with this because children are not uncivilized, they just haven't learners to be civilized

Ivonne Marquez
2/4/2014 07:11:07 am

I disagre with the quote "…events take place every day on our mean streets that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Golding's island"(1,Ebert) Because this says that the killing of this in this kind of story happen in the means of real life. How could he back up the answer? Theres no way of being able to find evidence that the killing happens as in a regular basis. Young people dont do that maybe in the book but it doesnt mean that us young adults would repeat the story of the book. In my opinion I've never seen a young kid killing someone on the street or anywhere else. Also I disagree beacuase those "monsters" which Ebert calls are young children that are 5-12. They were innocent children at one time but we know that without adult supervision and their imagination made them take the decision because they were desperate on making the right decision but they bacame savage and they just didnt how to handle the situation like adults thats how they wanted to handle it. But I also disagree because how aren't we unsuitable to not read this kind of things. This shows us that we are lucky to have adults to help us out. This isnt unsuitable to chidren this helps explain the things a young kid could face at any moment, and shows us that our imagination will take us farther than what we have expected and I REALLY disagree with what sir Ebert had said because those "monsters" that he calls tried to do the right thing and were once innocent they just didnt know how to take the situation.

Cale Zbierski
2/4/2014 08:58:44 am

I think lord of the flies is a toned down version of the atrocities we have to day. the first thing that comes to mind is slavery. In fact there are more slaves today than there were before the American Civil War. Also in today's society we have people fighting each other across the world such as the Ukraine riots and the Syrian government vs it's rebels. But what happens in the book is insane. In the book there was the want for power which lead to the murder of at least two of the boy's on the island, the weird part being you would think that children are not capable of murder. Even in today's society there have been very few murders by children. Another thing being what would have happened if Jack had the power of some governments? If anything he would be just as bad as the Syrian leader. Basically Lord of the Flies represents is that humans don't get worse we just have more power to do bad in modern society.

Brenda O.
2/4/2014 09:04:49 am

"…events take place every day on our mean streets that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Golding's island." I agree with the statement made by the critic. The boys in Lord of the Flies may have gone through a lot with death, yet the modern people experience death every day. Many of these deaths caused by insanity, drugs, or other common things. The boys experience death with killing one another and by accident, yet in our daily lives we witness different ways of death. Throughout the years death has escalated because of diseases, drugs, and daily accidents we may face walking down the street or at work. The boys may have been through a lot but in my opinion, they changed for their survival, in real life a person may cause death simply for the rush they feel, like Ralph felt when he hit the pig with a spear.

Michael S.
2/4/2014 10:57:10 am

I agree with the quote,"…events take place every day on our mean streets that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Golding's island." I agree with this quote because the things going on in today's society are much worse than what is described in The Lord of the Flies. Even though death is involved in the book, you must remember, IT IS A BOOK! NONE OF IT IS REAL! When you look at the things happening today, you must realize it is real and these things are actually happening. The things happening today are more horrifying than the things in Holding's book. The monsters in the book, ARE ONLY MONSTERS IN A BOOK!!

Brenda O.
2/4/2014 11:02:52 pm

I agree with you, what happens in the book may not be true. In reality we actually face more gruesome deaths or murder. Death happens on a daily basis unlike what happens to the boys.

Natalie DeLaCruz
2/7/2014 09:45:58 am

I agree, it is just monsters in a book. None of that ever happened, and the things that happen on these streets are real, but what if what happened in that book was real? That would make things way different right?

Berenice Rojas
2/4/2014 11:13:26 am

Roger Ebert critic of the book, Lord of the Flies, states that, "…events take place every day on our mean streets that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Golding's island." I agree with Roger because in our daily life we hear about worst event that happen. In the book Lord of the Flies innocent kids turn into savages and kill two boys, however, this boys have no adult to orient them and tell them what's wrong. We hear about teens or sometimes even young kids who murder their parents and siblings. These are kids who actually have adult orientation in school or at home but they still choose to commit cold-blooded acts like murdering their family. Adults who are fully conscient of the consequences of their acts do even worse things like taking the lives away of innocent people. Over all, I do agree with Roger's quote that worse events happen in the real world than in Golding's Island.

Selena F.
2/4/2014 11:24:37 am

In my opinion i think that the quote "...events take place everyday on our mean streets that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Goldings island." because well its in the book the children did not actually mean to kill one another they used things as a threat that got out of hand. while on our main streets people do it out of sanity or just for the heck of it its actually quite sick the things that people do for example the Aurora shooting he did it for absolute no reason. In the book "the Lord Of the Flies" when the boys kill simon they did not know it was simon and did it because of fear.therefore i agree with the critics quote.

Lisette Zamora
2/10/2014 06:47:54 am

Selena,
Even though Simon was not killed out of cruelty but out of fear, this still means that children are capable of anything. They go beyond the limits when they kill Piggy on purpose. Even then children still have emotions.

Amindra E
2/4/2014 11:29:00 am

I agree with the quote, kids might not be doing things like murdering one another but they are doing bad things maybe not intentionally, but they do and this develops. Also in the book the kids were doing horrible things but in real life they are witnessing which is just as bad as first hand, it's still a traumatic experience. And its nothing worse than what some kids are going through now.

tim burns
2/4/2014 11:32:29 am

I agree with the quote, for multiple reasons. The first is that those kids have a chance of rescue, some people have no chance of rescue from whatever situation they are in. the second reason that the quote is accurate is because of the exposure that all people of all ages have to negative things, which many children and adolescence didn't when the book was written.

Eric A.
2/8/2014 01:44:48 pm

I agree with you. Some people don't have a chance of a rescue, and they did. Yet, they decided to start killing each other, before putting their heads completely together to think of a plan to get off the island.

Eric A/
2/4/2014 11:50:11 am

I disagree with this statement. Yes, kids now a days are out doing drugs and crimes, but beating each other and killing each other doesn't happen everyday. "…events take place every day on our mean streets that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Golding's island." Yes, it may be that a child kills another child once in a while, but its not an everyday thing.

Aida c:
2/4/2014 12:03:50 pm

I personally disagree with the quote "...events take place everyday on our mean streets that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Goldings island," because today's world is messed up but not to the point where children kill each other. Thought kids today may be doing drugs and commiting crimes they don't go to the point of taking away someone's life. The people of today do things intentionally while the kids on the island did it because they didn't know better and they didn't have supervision, so many things happen today but there's always a reason behind it either anger or pure crazyness. The kids on the island may have killed each other but they didn't know how to handle things while society does.

Alejandra Serna
2/5/2014 12:30:42 pm

Aida I strongly agree with you because is true the kids weren't supervised by no adult, causing that awful crime not knowing what they were doing. But as a society we do know how to handle things but we refuse to do them . That's why I agree a hundred percent with you ! c:

tim burns
2/6/2014 03:23:57 am

This post changed my mind, I agree with Eric. Most people dont have to deal with what those kids delt with, and most people dont kill people like those kids did.

Jessica M.
2/4/2014 12:06:24 pm

I agree with this quote because I think that kids have become more ruthless. In the story the boys were well educated and came from probably a private school. But because of their neeed for survival, Jack and his tribe of savages became carried away with beoming measures which included killing in order try to remain in power. This was their only way of thinkibng due to the fact that they were alone. Now in days most kids have good influneces and a lot of things to keep them in the right track. but now wit the social media most teens are more sensitive to rude remarks and lead to end their lives o the lies of others. For example, the school shooting in Columbine happened because of a boy tired of getting bullied. Volence has definetly increased and for resons that were not as drastic as the boys in Lord of th Flies.

Ruby C
2/4/2014 12:11:44 pm

I do not agree with the quote, because even though there are more horrifying things happening in our society today it shouldn't make the problems for the boys on the island any different. Comparing the scene in which Simon was brutally murdered "At once the crowd surged after it, poured down the rock, leapt on to the beast, screamed, struck, bit, tore. There were no words, and no movements but the tearing of teeth and claws." (153) This scene in the book is no different from a boy in the streets who gets brutally jumped & either murdered or sent into a coma. Age doesn't matter in this situation because most kids know right from wrong. Good does not exist without evil and right does not weight without knowing the wrong.

melizza minjarez
2/4/2014 12:20:55 pm

I agree with Roger Eberts quote because he has a good point. Roger Ebert states that out in the real world things are worse than the things that happen in Goldings story. In the story the little boys stabb Simon to death, yea i wont deny that, thats pretty creepy and scary but in the real world worse things are hapeninng like in Syria, lttle boys are traned by terrorists. Children have been exposed to so many crimes like murder, recruiting, and abducting. Things in the real world are much worse than what is atually said in the story. In the end they get rescued, but when do these boy from the real world get rescued from these horrible things?

Paola Chavez
2/7/2014 05:18:05 am

I agree with the intensity of the conflicts occurring in our era, however, do the boys really get rescued? I disagree: the occasion and setting revolving the island was at the dawn of the next world war. Just as Golding described the theme of Lord of the Flies, " who will rescue the adult and his cruiser?" , next? This solemnly means,that at the end, the schools boys were being shipped out of the island but would soon take part in the horrifying warfare which in fact is the same reason why the story begins on the fail attempt to send school boys out of the battle into a more accommodating place. Therefore, the children are,likely, actually not being rescued since a terrible battle awaits them in "civilization". Overall, these factors should not be contrasted in gradation of terror, as it rather depends on its perspective time and context.

I agree with the intensity of the conflicts occurring in our era, however, do the boys really get rescued? I disagree: the occasion and setting revolving the island was at the dawn of the next world war. Just as Golding described the theme of lord the flies, " who will rescue the adult and his cruiser?" , next? This solemnly means, the schools boys were being shipped out of the island but would soon take part in the horrifying warfare which in fact is the same reason why the story begins on the fail attempt to send school boys out of the battle into a more accommodating place. Therefore, the children are ,likely, actually not being rescued since a terrible battle awaits them in "civilization". Overall, these factors should not be contrasted as the gradation of terror rather depends on its perspective time and context.

Natalie DeLaCruz
2/4/2014 12:29:09 pm

Roger Ebert remarked in his review that "…events take place every day on our mean streets that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Golding's island." I disagree with this quote, even if it wasn't intentional, two live were taken by the boys. What happened on the island may have even been seen as worse than what happens on "our mean streets." when was the last time we heard of a twelve year old killing someone? Yes, the boys didn't have someone there they could look up to and to show them how to deal with what they were going through, but they didn't have to go to the extent and kill, not just once, but twice. Finally, while they were having their own war against each other, there was also a raging war going on between the rest of the world. The things that take place on the street are not worse then what happened on the island between the boys.

Amindra E
2/11/2014 12:45:59 pm

I disagree we might not have 12 year old's running around committing murder but we have kids doing drugs like crazy and going through things like witnessing murder. Its just as bad.

Carolina Orozco
2/4/2014 01:07:31 pm

"…events take place every day on our mean streets that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Golding's island." I agree with this statement made by the critic. Life now in days is not some fairy tale we walk through, it's not even something many humans are proud of. Murders, suicides, bullying, hate, killings and self-harm are situations that happen on the daily. People, though not as young as these kids most of the time, perform these actions like its a natural thing, like its the correct thing. What is worse though, is that us, the people that hear about all of these things occurring or that take place, are so used to it that it no longer surprises us. We now expect these things, and that only displays the fact that our modern day world has become harsh on a regular basis, much more intense than what the Lord of the Flies exposed, though the children did face many hardships.

Paola Chavez
2/7/2014 05:42:31 am

I completely agree with your thought that the horrifying events are becoming a normality as generations often continue to see these acts which is something terrible that is transforming our world; however, do you really think this should be in comparison to the gradation of catastrophes-[for instance]Also know as the event of Lord of the Flies??? The ambition, youth, fear as well as many factors remodeled the infants into cannibals. In terms of news and terror, BOTH are to be likely/equally gradated since both acts undergo the same aspects of harmful penetration.

Gisselle Cervantes
2/5/2014 01:19:23 am

"…events take place every day on our mean streets that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Golding's island."
I personally disagree with this qoute for many reasons. Although in the Lord of The Flies , the kids did suffer brutal and violence, things in our society are more horrifying today. Violece in our society is an everyday thing because in our lives today someone is getting killed by the hands of others. Kids in school are not safe now a days. Theres shooting and violence everyday , and we have not yet found a way to stop this violence and we wont be able to stop it for a long time. The little kids in the story got crazy for the power they were gaining in the island, but also lost their innocence in many ways with violence. In this society , killing and beating happens everyday in our lives . For us life is no longer a pretty story we once believed as little kids.

Noemi Galdean
2/5/2014 03:23:43 am

Gisselle, i agree with you becasue its true, when you do look at our world today you can see that many people do gte hurt by eachother or they can hurt themselves.Little kids as well get hurt and when you read this story is as well as our society today and you can see that when you read The Lord of the Flies and you can see the way they fight over power because they all want control of eachother or something. So yes Gisselle i do hundred percent agree with you !

Noemi Galdean
2/5/2014 03:18:54 am

"...events take place every day on our mean streets that are more horrifiying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Golding's island."
I personally think that this quote can go both ways because when you think of it and you actully think of the events that do happen out on the mean streets there is so many people getting hurt maybe even worser then they do in the book "The Lord Of The Flies". When you actully take time to think about it everyday kids or teenagers hurt eachother or maybe even leading to the point of hurting themselves. As you see in the book the little monsters hurt themselves becasue they all want some sort of power towards someone or something. This is is not anything new, to people today they see this as "normal" you can say because they see it or hear it everyday from the news or from the society around them.So this quote can go both ways because many kids dont really care about how people veiw things they just go for what they think is right. Our main streets nowadays is worse because many little babies get hurt, people that are innocent get killed for example the shooting that happend at the school in Arapahoe i mean it was sad when you heard of it but many people just saw it as "Oh that happend again?" sort of thing and in the story when you first read it yea you see it as why would they do this to eachother but when you think of it isent our world like that as well or is it worse?

Meah Abeyta
2/5/2014 04:59:02 am

"...Events take place everyday on our mean streets, that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on goldings island." Stated Roger Ebert in his review. I do agree with this quote. People do things to harm one another every day out on the street, it may not be to the extreme of murdering them but they still cause some sort of pain. Whether its physical or emotional pain things we do everyday hurt people. The little monsters in Lord of the Flies not only harm others, but themselves as well. If youu think about it there are a lot of events in todays world that cause bad things to happen, it may not be on purpose but it dies happen. Half the time the little monsters didnt mean to harm eachother on purpose, things just happen. It was what they are used to in that situation. The same thing goes for in real life, children are raised in a place were crime is normal it happens on the daily. Life is no longer a peaceful perfect thing, it has turned curupt and things have changed.

Isabel Anguiano
2/5/2014 09:14:28 am

"…events take place every day on our mean streets that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Golding's island." I agree with this statement. The children in Lord of the Flies, did not have anybody to correct their behavior, they were doing fine in the beginning, but being far from civilization would make anyone become savage. In our streets you see even harsher crimes happening everyday. There are people being murdered without reason and with no mercy. The children were going crazy and didn't realize what they were doing, but people on our streets are conscious of what their actions are, yet they still do this.

Paola Chavez
2/5/2014 10:17:08 am

I disagree with the critics' claim of the "Lord of the Flies" being dated for modern societies because I think the symbolic intentional meaning of Golding could be suitable for our general conflicts in today's era. The beast is simply their icon whom they struggle with, whereas our nightmares may be focused upon different scenarios, yet we still undergo through the very similar changes that horrifying events cause. I honestly believe that negative events can't be measured into scales or categories such as mild, moderate, or severe.- Each are incomparable and cannot be underestimated over others: "..little monsters do to one another on Golding's island" is therefore breaking bounds of internal feelings and the nonexistent gradation. This controversy would impose each of our moral values, beliefs, or point of views. Yes, main issues in our society such as rape of inoffensive humans , participation of bullying leading to suicide, massacres by mindless people in that of schools and theatres, the vandalism that generations are growing into, etc. are horrifying scenes in our present "mean streets", but different crisis are perceived "stronger" during its perspective time in society. According to that, the ambition of power, loss of innocence, savagery, and evil, all tie in together to the "little monsters in Golding's island" where it supposedly took place at the dawn of the next world war. Warfare was occurring at the time which obviously elevated the fear. These outputs can be reflected through the rebellion in Jacks' decision to create a clan of hunters creating a division among the kids, the loss of childhood of those who reunite with Jack's team of savagery where they kill, through the shameful death of Piggy and Simon, and through the deeds to want to cause harm to each other and shift away from hope. Clearly the reaction that each horrifying event causes is alike, not in terms of specific conduction, but of the general penetration within one and our society.

Joshua Younger
2/10/2014 10:21:36 am

I see where you are coming from, you are saying that the beast is an example of anything that we are fighting in life (the same as zombies). The same also works for Jack's savage hunting group. I agree that the beast is a symbol of our most feared idea or conflict. However, I still think that the text and what happens on the streets could still be separate because in some countries, similar things might still happen like in the book and on the streets. Good job though, I am starting to think differently about this now.

Paola Chavez
2/5/2014 10:17:34 am

Joshua Younger
2/5/2014 10:46:52 am

I have a somewhat mixed opinion about this, to me they both have their own sinister effect to it. On one hand, I agree that what happens on our streets could be scarier because how knows what could happen. For example, people get murdered, robbed, kidnapped, and many other things on the streets {the pig scene}. That is scary because you do not know when, how, what is going to happen. However, the situation in "Lord of the Flies" is also terrifying. Having kids go on a murderous "hunt" is scary because we always envision children as innocent. This is frightening because something we could find so adorable or cute could betray us. That being said, it is only up to opinion which is scarier.

Daniela D
2/5/2014 10:56:30 am

"...events take place everyday on our mean streets that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Goldings Island " i personally agree with this statement made by Roger Elbert for many reasons. Even though there are 2 murders that happen in "Lord of the Flies " now a days we see and hear things much worse . In our society , many children commit murders caused by bullying , drugs , bad influence , etc. They seek for revenge in many ways and one of them is to commit murder. They do many cruel things to their victims way worse than what happened in the book. We know that Simon was brutally murderer by being stabbed, but we hear thing way worse that happen in the present days. Such as kids killing their family and parents. In our streets people get hurt every single day which makes me believe that this statement is true.

Isabel Anguiano
2/7/2014 11:45:10 am

I agree with you, there are worse things happening on our streets everyday. Like you said there are kids killing their own families. The children in Lord of the Flies, didn't know each other and what they did was because they were going insane. Everyday there are incidents occurring which are way worse than what the children suffered in the book Lord of the Flies.

Alejandra Serna
2/5/2014 12:20:39 pm

"...Events take place everyday on our mean streets, that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on goldings island." Stated Roger Ebert in his review. I personally disagree with this quote. Our world is messed up in many ways

Alejandra Serna
2/5/2014 12:27:32 pm


"...Events take place everyday on our mean streets, that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on goldings island." Stated Roger Ebert in his review. I personally disagree with this quote. Our world is messed up in many ways but not to the point where kids kill each other. This new era is about murder, bullying, self harm , and many other negative things but the thing is that as a society we do know what we do not like the boys in the " Lord of the Flies" . The boys did end up doing a major crime but the thing was that they weren't supervised by an adult, they didn't have no idea what they were doing; and as a society we do know what's going on but don't try to change things.

Isaiah Espinoza
2/9/2014 02:22:18 am

I agree with your statement but what if they do go to society? Will be worse or will they know what they did wrong?

Andrea Hernandez
2/5/2014 10:31:04 pm

I disagree with the statement "…events take place every day on our mean streets that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Golding's island." I believe what happened in Lord of The Flies is a toned down version of what actually happens in the streets. In real life, people kill one another, people turn on each other, they seek power, subordination to others, and that's exactly what LOTF was about. In LOTF when all the boys killed Simon, it is a reflection of how unconsciously man kind kills. This happens almost all the time in real life. I do believe though, that in the book, the events didn't seem so horrifying because of the way Golding's vague language. If he was maybe more explicit with his words, this man's quote would've been a little different.

Isaiah Espinoza
2/9/2014 02:18:16 am

I agree with this quotrebecause the little kids haven't experienced how it is on the streets.I mean they might have killedeach each other but in the mean steets its much worse. Lots of people try to get power by killing each other and what happens in Lord of the Flies is an example . I may be wrong but i say the mean streets are more horrrifying than what happens in the novel.

~Tony Marquez
2/9/2014 08:50:42 am

Isaiah,
If the boys were to experience how it is on our real life streets, what do you think it would be like for them? Would the boys join the crime or back away from it and change their mentality on murdering people? How are the mean streets much worse than the hunters in "Lord of the Flies" by William Golding, killing each other when they might need one another to survive? I agree with the argument you have that people strive for power by murdering people because on 9/11, Osama, gained power by attacking the twin towers but do you think that in real life people want to gain power more often than the kids in the book do?

Isaiah Espinoza
2/19/2014 10:00:18 am

I agree with your statement. Yeah I agree how the little kids in "Lord of the Flies' haven't experienced our world. It might be more dangerous for them where they are right now than the streets.

Susana Bedoya
2/9/2014 07:00:33 am

The quote by Roger Ebert states that "...Events take place everyday on our mean streets, that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on goldings island." I agree because our streets are filled with more horrifying things than what the boys do in the island, like school shootings and alot more violence, but i also dissagree because not everyone does these horrifying things because they might be afraid of what happens next. For example, in the book of "Lord of the Flies" the boys are first innocent and afraid to do evil things but they eventually loose their innocence and end up killing one another. So the author of "Lord of the Flies" might be saying that the human race might eventually get tired of the law and explode with violence and rebellion like in "Lord of the Flies".

Claudia Vera
2/9/2014 09:35:33 am

Susana,
I agree with you that violence is filled with school shootings and people dying. Also it is true that people don't have the guts to do violence because of the fear of getting in trouble with the law.

Gage cordova
2/9/2014 07:10:09 am

I agree with his remark the events that take place in the book aren't as horrific as the events that take places on the street. In the lord of the flies the boys go insane and the inner animal is reviled but on the streets people kill people just to kill plus it's a lot worse because the people on the streets have weapons.

Priscila Trevino
2/9/2014 08:06:35 am

I agree with the quote "…events take place every day on our mean streets that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Golding's island" because if you think about it, there are kids these days hurting each other with words or by physically hitting each other or even going suicidal. Then we have kids are more disrespectful with or with adult supervision. Yes it is sad that the boys in the book turned so savage that they killed one of their kind but really isn't any kid kind of cable of it since they are open so scissors and other sharp objects. Once again I know kids won't kill but they can definitely hurt each other. And don't get me started with adult because they are far worse with shootings, kidnapping, rape, drugs, robberies, and bombings. So therefore the book has its cruel sad moments but our world is really screwed up.

Fernanda Villalobos
2/9/2014 11:27:31 am

Priscila ~
I agree with your statement, adults on our mean streets are far more dangerous than young children on an island. Not much brutal events occurred on the island, it was instinct not generally intention. Adults everyday do commit crimes, shootings, kidnapping etc. Do you think if adults were stranded on an island they would think quick and work together because they are older and mature or would they be far more brutal and savage than the young children?

'Tony Marquez
2/9/2014 08:38:17 am

As critics argue that the novel "Lord of the Flies" by William Golding is somewhat unsuitable for modern audiences, Robert Ebert addressed in his review that, "...events take place everyday on our mean streets that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Golding's island." however, I disagree wit the quote. This quote ,in my opinion, is not entirely true because the use of Golding's language is far more gore-like than what really happens in our streets in modern times. The "rape" scene when Jack and his hunters stab the pig to death through its butt hole would be very graphic compared to real life crimes. Although lunatics in real life kidnap and cut their victims into small pieces can be very horrifying, the scenes where the hunters murder Simon and Piggy are far more intimidating simply because the little boys have their little brains fully stained with crime and massacre. The quote is nothing to agree with because the boys enjoy the killing and domination over creatures when real life people haven't done a murderous act recently.

Claudia Vera
2/9/2014 09:32:42 am

In the novel of Lord of Flies, Critics argue that the novel in general is somewhat dated and unsuitable for modern audiences. Literary and movie critic Roger Ebert remarked in his review that "…events take place every day on our mean streets that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Golding's island." I agree with this quote because violence is everywhere. Compare to what we used to have in the old days we can't go anywhere without been safe. People carry guns everywhere they go. The disagreements of the kids in the island shows that society go against everything we try to make for ourselves. Overall, I do agree on the quote because violence happens everywhere.

Angel Salazar
2/9/2014 10:40:20 am

I agree with you Claudia, violence is everywhere and if you really think about it violence just worsens as time goes on.Terrorism and shootings on young innocent kids are 2 unfortunate examples.There are worse things happening on the worlds mean streets.

Angel Salazar
2/9/2014 10:35:14 am

"...events take place everyday on our mean streets that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Golding's island" I agree with this quote.All the deaths were all accidental except one.Simon was seen as the beast and was accidentally killed.Piggy was the only kid intentionally killed.If you really think about It, the kids acts arent nearly as close to those of Charles Mansons (serial killer) acts.Yeah at one point they enjoyed the feeling of killing but not nearly as close to a serial killers.There are far more worst things happening on the mean streets than on Golding's island.

Anahi Figueroa
2/9/2014 10:55:30 am

Angel,
I agree with your claim. There is way more violence today than what Golding shows,"In Lord of the Flies". Golding just introduced murder ,but there is far more crime and violence shown to young children.Today there are millions of cruel and worse crimes taken action today.

Anahi Figueroa
2/9/2014 10:50:36 am

Golding's tragic literature,"Lord of the Flies", has been viewed as inappropriate and unsuitable for today's modern era. Literature critic, Robert Ebert claims that,"…events take place every day on our mean streets that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Golding's island." I completely agree with Ebert because violence and crime are very known in modern society. As technology is improving there are more occasions where violence and crime are seen. Children at a very young age learned the art of cruelty. Also, society is teaching the children to be savages, rather than learning morals. Furthermore, I agree because there is far more crime and violence today than shown in,"Lord of the Flies". For example, murderers find new techniques that are far more complex and cruel than,"Lord of the Flies." In conclusion I completely agree with Ebert's claim.

Shanel Francisco
2/9/2014 01:01:17 pm

Anahi, I totally agree with you! Society and technology are major factors in why events far more beyond complex than those that occur in "Lord of the Flies" are so common in this age. Violence is more common today than it ever was when Golding published this novel.

Fernanda Villalobos
2/9/2014 11:12:33 am

Literary and movie critic, Roger Ebert remarked that in "Lord of the Flies", "…events take place every day on our mean streets that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Golding's island." Other critics suggest the novel is somewhat dated and unsuitable for modern audiences.I agree with Roger Ebert's statement, it is more likely to see horrid events taking place on our mean streets each day rather than, reading a novel where stranded children make poor choices. In our everyday lives events take place where homicides and shootings occur with intentions. It is a more dangerous situation and many can be killed or injured. In Golding's island there is children stranded whom are under no supervision,and no "real" death occurred . Simon was killed due to the fact the children were frightened by a "monster" that supposedly lurked the island. Piggy was killed by a rock that was pushed by only one person, it wasn't a death by knife or gun, what killed Piggy was an object. The boy probably didn't mean for the rock to kill Piggy he was most likely expecting an injury. Overall on Golding's Island nothing as brutal as what takes place everyday occurred. It was just an island isolated from rules and adults containing young children afraid from a "monster" and then let their insanity get the best of them. Thus I agree with Roger Ebert's review on "Lord of the Flies".

Cynthia Sanchez
2/9/2014 11:49:46 am

I like your logic and agree with most of what you are saying. You make a very good argument, but what about the fact that at such a young age they are fighting for power and abandoning one another. Also, even though they might have meant for no one to get hurt during the murders, what of the fact that they showed no guilt for what they did and did not show sadness. Also, does it not say a lot about the boys that they murdered the pig so willingly? Had they had more time on the island would they have shown a much more developed anti-social personality and been ready to murder each other purposefully?

Priscila Trevino
2/10/2014 12:09:18 am

I agree with you Ferni because it is true that they did not intetionally try to kill Simon. It was more of a defense mechanisism from the "monster" since they were frightened. Then, with Piggy it is true that Roger did kill him but he just wanted to injure him and did not expect to actually kill him. Roger is cosidered a bully who likes to hurt others but not to the point of killing but on our "mean streets" there are kids who do kill others and this is intetional. So you are totally right :D

Sarah M.
2/11/2014 03:45:28 am

~Fernanda
I agree with you entirely, but where do you think the line between real horrors and false horrors is? If real horrors of our "mean streets" are more horrifying than that of Golding's "monsters", where does one draw the line of real and false horrors? Do you think Golding's "Lord of the Flies" is a microcosm of the world's younger generation? What makes you feel the word "insanity" is appropriate?

Cynthia Sanchez
2/9/2014 11:40:01 am

I do not agree with Roger Ebert's remark that "…events take place every day on our mean streets that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Golding's island." Sure there are terrible murders and kidnappings and all sorts of evil acts occurring every day, but that does not make the events that occurred on the island any less tragic. Not only are the murderers mere children, but they act as if they have no remorse for their actions. Also, their evil acts escalate and spread quickly to one another, almost like a contagious disease. This book is not outdated because it is a perfect example of humankind's primal acts of survival and need of power, which can still be seen in society today.

Asia Shields
2/10/2014 09:01:21 am

-Cynthia
How is the kid's accidental murder in "Lord of the Flies" worse than all the murders, kidnappings, etc. that happen every day on pourpose? Also, the little kids had absolutly no adults there to tell them right from wrong. People in real life do these things, get punished, and do them over and over again. I'm sorry, but I completely and utterly disagree with you there.

Shanel Francisco
2/9/2014 12:55:28 pm

"...events take place every day on our mean streets that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Golding's island."
I completely agree with this quote, violence in this day and age are a lot more common now then ever before. During the time of "The Lord of the Flies", people would probably never have been able to predict the horrors that occur every day in this world. Although these kids have murdered some young men, that is nothing new to the people of these modern times. Every day you look on the news, you constantly hear of murders and crimes being committed right in your home town, which we have gotten so accustomed to that it has become normal! What these young men have committed on that island may have been something completely foreign back then but are somewhat of a has been now. So the boys murdered Simon, don't we all here about this during gang fights? This proves that "Lord of the Flies" maybe somewhat dated as critics have stated.

Anonymous
2/10/2014 06:42:47 am

Asia Shields
2/10/2014 08:52:59 am

Roger Ebert's review on "Lord of the Flies" states, "...events take place every day on our mean streets that are more horrifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Golding's island." I very much agree with Roger because kids in real life kill each other on pourpose, and don't feel guilty about doing it and keep doing it. In "Lord of the Flies" the two times that they killed were on accident. The first time it was dark and they killed Simon. The last time was that Piggy was in the wrong spot and the bolder accidentaly fell on top of him. In real life people could be shot or kidnapped for no reason, and people non't care and don't try to do anything about it. That is why Roger Ebert's review on "Lord of the Flies" is completely true.

Sarah M.
2/11/2014 03:37:12 am

I agree with the quote because it took a long time for the children in "The Lord of the Flies" to sink to killing each other. Everyday, in today's society, more and more people are getting into gangs, drugs, or other violent and dangerous stuff. In Golding's novel the children don't start outright killing each other until the accident with Simon. In fact, the boys all got along until Ralph became more upset than he ever was when the fire went out and a ship passed right by. Afterwards jack became offended. The boys the split into two groups and accidently killed Simon. When Roger outright killed Piggy, then the boys descended into true savagery. Whereas in real life children are descending into savagery and becoming desensitized every five minutes. Thus Golding's novel cannot compare to the horrors of real life.

Kayla Prieto
2/12/2014 12:45:03 pm

" ...Events take place everyday on our mean streets that are more horiifying than anything the little monsters do to one another on Goldings island ." i agree with this quote because theres people out there who hurt themselves or others everyday, either with suicide, bullying, or school shootings . its the same thongg basically the kids still get killed or hurt . they do it for different reasons but it all is still the same outcome . in the book roger pushes the boulder onto piggy so they could have more power over the children on the island . Piggy didnt even do anything to hurt anyone and for him to die ? And in real life theres crazy people who try shooting other in schools or theaters and why ? all because there mad about something or they want something . Its all for different reason but yet it all has the same outcomes .


Comments are closed.

    A Place to Think

    Because there just isn't enough time in class.


    Weekly poll:

    Archives

    February 2014
    January 2014

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.